Why Your Best Hire Isn't Performing
You hired them for a reason. Strong resume. Great interview. Everyone in the room liked them.
Six months in, something's off. They're not hitting the mark. Meetings drag. Results are inconsistent. You're frustrated, and so are they.
Here's the hard truth: it's probably not a skills problem.
The Real Issue Is Fit, Not Ability
Most hiring processes are designed to evaluate competence — past experience, technical ability, cultural "vibe." What they don't measure is whether the person is naturally wired for the role.
Some people are built to hunt. Put them in a process-heavy operations role and they'll suffocate. Some people are built to execute detailed, repeatable systems. Put them in front of ambiguous growth challenges and they'll stall.
It's not a character flaw. It's a mismatch.
Gallup found that companies succeed in hiring the right person only 18% of the time. That means most of your team — statistically — is in roles that don't align with how they're wired.
What You're Actually Paying For
Think about what misfit costs you. It's not just the salary.
It's the manager time spent compensating. The team friction when someone slows the group down. The opportunity cost of a role that's filled but not producing. And eventually, the turnover — which runs roughly 2x the annual salary of the position to replace.
Multiply that across your leadership team and you're looking at a significant drag on the business. One that doesn't show up cleanly on any report.
A Better Approach
The best operators I've worked with don't rely on instinct alone. They use behavioral data to validate what the interview process can't reveal — how someone is naturally motivated, how they process information, how they respond to pressure and pace.
When you understand that about a person before you place them — or before you decide they're failing — everything changes. You stop guessing. You start designing.
The question isn't whether your hire is talented. It's whether they're in the right seat.
Get that right, and performance follows. Get it wrong, and no amount of coaching closes the gap.
If your team isn't performing the way you expect, I'd welcome the conversation. Schedule a call.